Get ready for a thrilling expansion of the We Were Liars universe, because the secrets don’t stop with Season 1. Just when you thought the drama was over, E. Lockhart drops a bombshell with the release of We Fell Apart, a new novel set in the same world as the ultra-wealthy Sinclair family. But here’s where it gets controversial: this isn’t just a sequel—it’s a standalone story that dares to explore a different corner of this opulent, mystery-laden universe. And this is the part most people miss: while We Were Liars Season 2 is still in the works, We Fell Apart offers a fresh set of characters, secrets, and mysteries to keep fans hooked.
Meet Matilda, a young woman invited to spend the summer with her long-lost father, the reclusive artist Kingsley Cello. When she arrives at his crumbling, castle-like estate on Hidden Beach, Kingsley is nowhere to be found. Instead, she encounters her half-brother Meer, a former child star named Brock, and a brooding boy named Tatum. Together, they form a new web of intrigue that feels both familiar and startlingly new. But what’s truly bold is how Lockhart weaves this story into the We Were Liars universe without making it feel forced. Is it a clever expansion or a risky departure? You decide.
Lockhart reveals that the idea for We Fell Apart was inspired by a visit to a stunning, decaying property on Martha’s Vineyard—a place that screamed Gothic beach house. Initially, it was meant to be a standalone novel, but as Lockhart worked on the We Were Liars TV show, the worlds began to merge. And this is where it gets fascinating: Matilda and her companions trespass onto Beechwood Island, the heart of the Sinclair family’s dark history. It’s a ghoulish, teenage adventure that offers a fresh perspective on the We Were Liars world, while still standing on its own.
But here’s the kicker: while We Fell Apart shares the same thematic DNA—exploring the complexities of family, secrets, and identity—it’s set in a very different kingdom. Beechwood Island, ruled by the Sinclairs, is an establishment kingdom, while Kingsley’s estate represents an alternative, almost rebellious counterpart. Is this a critique of the Sinclairs’ values, or a parallel exploration of power and legacy? Lockhart leaves that open to interpretation.
As for Season 2 of We Were Liars, showrunners Julie Plec and Carina Adly MacKenzie are tight-lipped but promise surprises. They’ve read We Fell Apart, so who knows what elements might sneak into the show? Meanwhile, Lockhart’s next TV project, Genuine Fraud, starring Rain Spencer, is already generating buzz. With Sinead Daly at the helm, it’s shaping up to be another must-watch.
So, what do you think? Is We Fell Apart a brilliant expansion of the We Were Liars universe, or does it risk diluting the original story? And how do you feel about Lockhart’s subtle critiques of wealth and family dynamics? Let’s debate in the comments—because one thing’s for sure: this universe is far from done surprising us.
